NWMI Tells Supreme Court Police Cannot Curb Journalists Under Guise of Crowd Control
Media body submits rejoinder stating newsgathering rights do not depend on state accreditation

In 30 seconds
- NWMI told the Supreme Court that crowd control does not justify restraining working journalists
- Media body stated personal liberty cannot be curtailed by calling detention a verification measure
- Reporting rights are protected under Article 19(1)(a) irrespective of medium or formal accreditation
- The rejoinder challenges Delhi Police submissions concerning October protests against the Chief Election Commissioner
- More than thirty journalists were detained across central Delhi during demonstrations on October 10 and 11
- Police cannot condition press protections on Press Council guidelines or official government accreditation cards
- NWMI argued that recording public protests for dissemination qualifies as legitimate news gathering
The Network of Women in Media, India has informed the Supreme Court that police forces cannot justify restraining working reporters by terming the action as crowd control, nor can they interfere with personal liberty simply by avoiding terms like arrest or detention.
The media organisation made these submissions in a rejoinder filed before the apex court, challenging a counter affidavit by the Delhi Police. The matter relates to the removal and mistreatment of journalists covering demonstrations against the Chief Election Commissioner in New Delhi during October.
In its rejoinder, the organisation highlighted that the right to gather and report news is not dependent on state accreditation, formal employment with an established media house, or the possession of an employer-issued identity card. It argued that Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution safeguards freedom of speech and expression across platforms, maintaining that anyone documenting public action for publication is engaged in legitimate news dissemination.
The filing noted that the Delhi Police admitted to placing journalists in police vehicles for verification before releasing them. The journalists body argued that describing such measures as crowd control, bona fide errors, or mistaken identity cannot provide lawful authority to restrict professional duties and personal liberty.
More than 30 reporters were detained across central Delhi on October 10 and 11 during public demonstrations opposing the Election Commission's Special Intensive Revision. Several media professionals reported facing manhandling, threats, and orders to delete captured footage while attempting to cover the public demonstrations.
TTV News follows a published editorial policy. Spotted an error? Request a correction.
Related

Reservation Must Continue Till Inequality Persists, Says Tukaram Mundhe
Maharashtra FDA chief also cautions youth against misleading claims by supplement brands

Bulandshahr Police Arrest Woman in Fatal Crime Involving Three Year Old Girl
Accused neighbour was tracked down by a sniffer dog after the child went missing in Kotwali area

Central Tax Superintendents Announce Nationwide Black Badge Protest from November 23
Officers demand cadre restructuring and faster promotions after decades of career stagnation
